![Best Guayabitos Restaurants: 15 Top-Rated Spots [2026]](/_next/image?url=%2Fimages%2Fblog%2Fel-comelon-seafood.webp&w=1920&q=75)
Best Guayabitos Restaurants: 15 Top-Rated Spots [2026]
Quick Answer
Best overall: Restaurante Pineda — 4.6★ rating with 6,947 reviews
Best for seafood: El Comelón
This list: 15 restaurants ranked by 16,752 combined Google reviews (avg 4.5★)
How We Ranked These Restaurants
This isn't a subjective "best of" list. We analyzed 16,752 Google reviews across 125+ restaurants in Guayabitos and the surrounding Jaltemba Bay area. Our ranking formula weights:
- Google rating (60% weight) — Quality as rated by actual diners
- Review volume (40% weight, log scale) — Consistency and popularity over time
The result: a data-driven list of restaurants that have earned their reputation through thousands of real customer experiences.
Budget Breakdown
Budget ($)
- • Street tacos: $1-2 each
- • Quesadillas: $2-3
- • Comida del día: $5-8
- • Average meal: $5-10
Mid-Range ($$)
- • Pescado zarandeado: $8-12
- • Seafood plates: $10-15
- • Pizza/pasta: $8-14
- • Average meal: $12-20
Upscale ($$$)
- • Beachfront dining: $15-30
- • Fresh lobster: $20-35
- • Multi-course: $25-50
- • Average meal: $25-50+
The 15 Best Restaurants in Guayabitos
Ranked by a combination of Google rating and review volume. Each restaurant has been verified with current contact information and hours.
Restaurante Pineda
Mexican • Rincón de Guayabitos
One of the most-reviewed restaurants in the bay with 6,947 Google reviews with beachfront views
What to order: Pescado zarandeado (grilled fish) or fresh ceviche
Pro tip: Arrive early or expect a wait during peak hours (1-3pm lunch, 7-9pm dinner)
El Pollito
Mexican • La Peñita de Jaltemba
A proven local favorite with over 1k reviews
What to order: Ask the waiter for the house specialty
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
La Casita de Irma
Mexican • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Consistently rated 4.5★ across 988 reviews
What to order: Ask the waiter for the house specialty
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
El Comelón
Mexican Seafood • La Puerta de la Lima
Consistently rated 4.5★ across 911 reviews featuring live music
What to order: Pescado zarandeado (grilled fish) or fresh ceviche
Pro tip: Ask for the garlic shrimp (camarones al ajillo) – locals swear it's the best in the bay. Arrive before 1pm on weekends to avoid the crowds. Live music typically starts around 3pm on Saturdays and Sundays.
Aloha Restaurant & Pizza
Pizza • La Peñita de Jaltemba
A proven local favorite with over 1k reviews
What to order: Wood-fired pizza with local toppings
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
Guayami Vice
Mexican • Rincón de Guayabitos
Exceptional 4.9★ rating from locals and visitors with beachfront views
What to order: Pescado zarandeado (grilled fish) or fresh ceviche
Pro tip: Reservations recommended, especially on weekends
La Piña Loca
Fast food • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Solid 4.5★ rating from the community
What to order: Ask the waiter for the house specialty
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
Restaurant La Avenida
Breakfast • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Consistently rated 4.4★ across 578 reviews
What to order: Chilaquiles or huevos rancheros
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
Deras Pizza
Pizza • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Exceptional 4.7★ rating from locals and visitors
What to order: Wood-fired pizza with local toppings
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
La vitola Italiana comida
Pizza • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Solid 4.6★ rating from the community
What to order: Wood-fired pizza with local toppings
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
El Rodeo
Italian • Rincón de Guayabitos
A proven local favorite with over 1k reviews
What to order: Pasta or wood-fired pizza
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
HANAMI
Japanese • La Peñita de Jaltemba
Solid 4.5★ rating from the community
What to order: Fresh sushi rolls with local catch
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
Buhardilla
Italian • Rincón de Guayabitos
Solid 4.5★ rating from the community
What to order: Wood-fired pizza with local toppings
Pro tip: Reservations recommended, especially on weekends
Restaurant pizza & grill Aloha
Grill • Rincón de Guayabitos
Solid 4.6★ rating from the community
What to order: Grilled meats or seafood platter
Pro tip: Cash preferred — bring pesos
Vista Guayabitos
Mexican • Rincón de Guayabitos
Solid 4.4★ rating from the community with pleasant outdoor seating
What to order: Pescado zarandeado (grilled fish) or fresh ceviche
Pro tip: Reservations recommended, especially on weekends
Dining Tips
Timing
- Lunch (comida): 1-3 PM — The main meal. Best prices and freshest specials.
- Dinner: 7-9 PM — Busiest time. Arrive early for popular spots.
Payment
- Cash is king: Many restaurants are cash-only (pesos preferred)
- Tipping: 10-15% is appreciated but not mandatory
- ATMs: Available in town center with reasonable rates
Must-Try Dish
Pescado zarandeado — Nayarit's signature dish. Whole fish butterflied, grilled over charcoal with garlic, lime, and spices. Available at most seafood restaurants for $8-15.
Quick Reference
| # | Restaurant | Rating | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Restaurante Pineda | 4.6★ | $$ | Families |
| 2 | El Pollito | 4.3★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 3 | La Casita de Irma | 4.5★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 4 | El Comelón | 4.5★ | $$ | Families |
| 5 | Aloha Restaurant & Pizza | 4.4★ | $$ | Budget-friendly |
| 6 | Guayami Vice | 4.9★ | $ | Sunset dining |
| 7 | La Piña Loca | 4.5★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 8 | Restaurant La Avenida | 4.4★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 9 | Deras Pizza | 4.7★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 10 | La vitola Italiana comida | 4.6★ | $ | Budget-friendly |
| 11 | El Rodeo | 4★ | $$ | Budget-friendly |
| 12 | HANAMI | 4.5★ | $$ | Budget-friendly |
| 13 | Buhardilla | 4.5★ | $$$ | Drinks |
| 14 | Restaurant pizza & grill Aloha | 4.6★ | $$ | Budget-friendly |
| 15 | Vista Guayabitos | 4.4★ | $$ | Families |
Key Takeaways
- ✓Restaurante Pineda leads with 6,947 reviews — The most-reviewed restaurant in Guayabitos for a reason.
- ✓Average rating of 4.5★ across the top 15 — These are genuinely good restaurants, not tourist traps.
- ✓Most are budget-friendly — You can eat very well for $10-15 USD per meal.
- ✓Pescado zarandeado is the must-try — Nayarit's signature grilled fish, available at most seafood spots.
Related Articles
Full Restaurant Directory (125+ listings)
Search and filter all restaurants in Guayabitos with ratings, reviews, and contact info.
Pescado Zarandeado: Complete Guide
Everything about Nayarit's signature dish — what it is, where to find it, how to eat it.
Budget Breakdown: Week in Guayabitos
Complete cost breakdown including food, accommodation, activities, and more.
Things to Do in Guayabitos
Complete activities guide including water sports, day trips, and local favorites.
Stay Steps from the Best Restaurants
Casa Nayarit puts you walking distance from top-rated restaurants, the market comedores, and evening taco carts. Full kitchen for cooking your market finds.
View Casa Nayarit